#  Earning to Give: How Effective is Altruism in Occupational Choice? 

Jonathan Morduch and Ariane Szafarz

June 10, 2026

How can prosocial workers have the greatest impact on society? One way is to earn a high wage at a for-profit firm and then donate as much as possible to favored causes. Philosophers call this “earning to give,” a concept associated with the effective altruism movement, which promotes a cost-benefit approach to philanthropy. An alternative option is to work directly for a nonprofit that contributes to the social good, giving less money but donating time and uncompensated productivity. In making these choices, people also need to worry about covering their own living costs. In this context, we develop a theoretical model and demonstrate that the “effectiveness” of altruistic choices hinges on the worker’s budget constraint and the nature of their altruism. Misalignment between workers and nonprofits occurs for purely altruistic, cash-constrained workers. With impure altruism—where the motivation to work at the nonprofit stems partly from “warm glow” feelings—cash-constrained workers can reach the social optimum. Such impure altruism, though, is likely to misalign the choices of wealthier workers.



File

 [Morduch-and-Szafarz-Earning-to-Give-June-2026.pdf](/files/faculty/publications/Morduch-and-Szafarz-Earning-to-Give-June-2026.pdf)

 

 

Wagner Faculty

[Jonathan J. Morduch](/community/faculty/jonathan-j-morduch)

 

 

Financial Access Initiative

[Economics](/impact/research/topics/economics)

[Philanthropy and Fundraising](/taxonomy/term/8785371)

[Public &amp; Nonprofit Orgs](/impact/research/topics/public-nonprofit-orgs)